Javascript generators and functional reactive programming

tl;dr: ECMAScript 6 introduces a language feature called generators, which are really great for working with asynchronous code that uses promises. But they do not work well for functional reactive programming.

ES6 generators allow asynchronous code to be written in a way that looks synchronous. This example uses a hypothetical library called Do (implementation below) that makes promises work with generators:

var postWithAuthor = Do(function*(id) {
var post   = yield getJSON('/posts/'+id)
var author = yield getJSON('/users/'+post.authorId)
return _.assign(post, { author: author })
})

Do(function*() {
var post = yield postWithAuthor(3)
console.log('Post written by', post.author.name)
})()


It is possible to use generators now in Node.js version 0.11 by using the --harmony flag. Or you can use Traceur to transpile ES6 code with generators into code that can be run in any ES5-compatible web browser.

I recently saw an informative talk from Jacob Rothstein on Co and Koa. Those are libraries that make full use of generators to make writing asynchronous code pleasant. The implementation of the above example in Co is almost identical.

Co operates on promises and thunks, allowing them to be expanded with the yield keyword. It has nice options for pulling nested asynchronous values out of arrays and objects, running asynchronous operations in parallel, and so forth. One can even use try / catch to catch errors thrown in asynchronous code!

Co is specialized for asynchronous code. But when I look at it I see something that is really close to being a monad comprehension - very much like the do notation feature in Haskell. With just a little tweaking, the use of generators that Co has pioneered can almost be generalized to work with any kind of monad.

For example, libraries like RxJs and Bacon.js implement event streams, which are a lot like promises, except that callbacks on event streams can run more than once. This example uses Bacon to manage a typeahead search feature in a web interface:

var searchQueries = Do(function*(searchInput) {
var inputs = $(searchInput).asEventStream('keyup change') var singleInputEvent = yield inputs var query = singleInputEvent.target.value if (query.length > 2) { // passes the query through return Bacon.once(query) } else { // excludes this query from the searchQueries stream return Bacon.never() } }) var resultView = Do(function*(searchInput, resultsElement) { var query = yield searchQueries(searchInput) var results = yield Bacon.fromPromise(getJSON('/search/'+ query))$(resultsElement).empty().append(
results.map(function(r) { return $('<li>').text(r) } ) }) resultView('#search', '#results')  The idea is that when the user enters more than two characters of text into a search box, a background request is dispatched and search results appear on the page automatically. This example requires a library that is a little more general than Co, that is able to operate on Bacon event streams in addition to promises and thunks. Here is a basic implementation of that library: function Do(mkGen) { return function(/* arguments */) { var gen = mkGen.apply(null, arguments) return next(); function next(v) { var res = gen.next(v) return handleResult(res) } function handleError(e) { var res = gen.throw(e) if (typeof res !== undefined) { return handleResult(res) } else { return e } } function handleResult(res) { return res.done ? res.value : flatMap(res.value, next, handleError) } } } function flatMap(m, f, e) { if (typeof m.then === 'function') { return m.then(f, e) // handles promises } else if (typeof m.flatMap === 'function') { return m.flatMap(f).onError(e) // handles Bacon event streams (or properties) } else { throw new TypeError("No implementation of flatMap for this type of argument.") } }  This is the function that makes the example at the top of this post work. It is a simplified version of what Co does - the difference being that Do delegates to a flatMap function to handle yielding. We just need an implementation of flatMap that can operate on some different monad types. The one above works with promises or with Bacon event streams. An implementation that is easier to extend would be nice; but I will leave that problem for another time. Unfortunately, the Bacon example does not work. Streams - unlike promises - get many values. That means that the code in each generator has to run many times (once for each stream value). But ES6 generators are not reentrant: after resuming a generator from the point of a given yield expression, it is not possible to jump back to that entry point again (assuming the generator does not contain a loop). With the Bacon example, after the first keyup or change event the search result list will just stop updating. Getting synchronous-style functional reactive programming to work well would require immutable, reentrant generators. ES6 generators are stateful: every invocation of a generator changes the way that it will behave on the next invocation. In other words, a generated is mutated on every invocation: var gen = function*() { yield 1 yield 2 return 3 } g = gen() // initialize the generator assert(g.next().value === 1) assert(g.next().value === 1) assert(g.next().value === 3) assert(g.next().value === undefined)  An immutable implementation would return a new object with a function for the next generator entry point, instead of mutating the original generator: var g = gen() var g1 = g.next() assert(g1.value === 1) var g2 = g1.next() assert(g2.value === 2) var g3 = g2.next() assert(g3.value === 3) // We can go back to previous entry points. assert(g1.next().value === 2) assert(g.next().value === 1)  An immutable generator could be implemented with some simple syntactic transforms. The basic case: function*(args...) { preceding_statements var y = yield x following_statements }  would transform to: function(args...) { preceding_statements return { value: x, next: function(y) { following_statements } } }  The next property is returned is a generator that is used to invoke the next step. In this view generators are just functions. Not only that - a generator is a closure that has access to the results of previous steps via closure scope. There would just need to be a few cases to handle appearances of yield in a return statement, a try-catch block, or as its own statement. With that kind of stateless design, the Bacon example would work fine. But as far as I know, there is no plan for stateless, reentrant generators in ECMAScript. It is possible to make functional reactive programming work with non-reentrant generators by using loops in the generators. This approach is not as general or as composable. Asynchronous pieces would have to be declared specially at the top of the function, for example. var searchQueries = function(searchInput) { var inputs =$(searchInput).asEventStream('keyup change')
frp(inputs, function*(inputs_) {
var singleInputEvent
while (true) {
singleInputEvent = yield inputs_
query = singleInputEvent.target.value
if (query.length > 2) {
// passes the query through
yield Bacon.once(query)
}
else {
// excludes this query from the searchQueries stream
yield Bacon.never()
}
}
})
}


Notice that yield is overloaded to accept asynchronous values and to return results - which requires some awkward logic to inspect generator values. I do not know how to implement resultView as a loop, since it requires combining two event streams: search queries and JSON responses. I do not see any advantage of loops in generators over asynchronous-style callbacks. But maybe someone more imaginative than me can come up with a more elegant solution.

Edited 2014-08-04: Fixed broken link, fixed incorrect indentation in code snippets.

Edited 2014-08-05: The hypothetical generators that I describe are immutable, not stateless. Thanks to Blixt for pointing out the distinction.